I was really hoping that this would just blow over, but it clearly isn't going to, so here it is:
On Wednesday evening, after going back and forth on whose responsibility it is to distribute layoff letters in the Department of Public Works, City Attorney Joe
Scala threw a packet of letters at Commissioner of Public Works Skip
Scirocco, hitting him in the back, although he says he only intended to throw the envelope at
Scirocco's feet.
Scirocco said that after delivering the first of 28 lay off letters, he realized that individuals losing their jobs were asking a lot of questions that he was not equipped to answer. These were questions that should probably have been addressed by the city's Human Resource Manager. The problem being, of course, that the city does not currently have an HR manager. City Attorney Joe
Scala has been empowered to fill in as HR manager in some capacities.
So, here's my take:
Scirocco is within his rights to ask for help in answering technical, legal questions relating to layoffs. BUT, knowing
Scirocco, and having heard both sides' description of the confrontation, it does not sound like the commissioner clearly articulated his request for this kind of help, but instead left the letters without explanation on
Scala's desk. According to Civil Service, delivering the letters can also be handled by Human Resources, but
Scala's role as a stand-in HR person is not clearly defined, so he may be right in saying that it's not his job.
From
Scala's perspective, it appears to be the appointing authority's job to deliver the layoff letters, so without a good explanation of what
Scirocco wanted when he left the letters, why would he want to get involved in the messy delivery of such documents? BUT, was it professional of him to throw the envelope at an elected official? Probably not. It certainly doesn't fit in with the Mayor's stated agenda of bringing decorum and civility to City Hall, a point that outgoing Commissioner of Public Safety was eager to point out this afternoon.
The bottom line, from where I'm sitting, is that the city is doing something it has never done before with this amount of layoffs. No one is really happy about it, and who can blame them? Emotions are running high, and since we're all human, confrontations can happen. Let's just hope that this is the worst we see.
Also,
Horatio has a good take on all this.